Franciscan Voice Canada
  • Welcome
    • About This Site
    • Who Are We?
    • Events
  • ACTION
    • Take Action
    • Fraternity in Action
    • Franciscans International & OFM JPIC
    • Pope Francis
    • Prayer Corner
  • Blog
    • Andrew's Blog
    • Margaret's Blog
    • Guest Blog
  • Newsletters
    • the Common Good
    • JPIC Communique OFS Canada
    • from the Franciscan Family
    • Laudato Si' Dialogues
  • NEWS
    • Care of Creation
    • Christian Solidarity
    • Ethical Use of Resources
    • Fair Trade
    • Food Security
    • Indigenous Peoples
    • Trafficking & Slavery
    • Peace
    • Poverty
    • Refugees/Migrants
  • Resources
    • JPIC in Fraternity
    • FI Publications
    • Films
    • Publications
  • LINKS
    • Franciscan Resources
    • Vatican & Church
    • Media/News Sources
    • Advocacy Sources
  • Contact Us

August 2021 Blog

8/7/2021

5 Comments

 
August 2021 Franciscan Voice Canada
Blog by Andrew Conradi, ofs; JPIC & Laudato si’ Animator
who acknowledges and thanks the Lkwungen People, (of the place to smoke herring)  also known as the Songhees and Esquimalt First Nations, 
for allowing me to live, pray, work, and play on their lands.

​
Part 1:  LAUDATO SI’ MOVEMENT
Picture
Picture
Launched: 29 July 2021: Learn More

Pope Francis:
“God will give us a new name, which contains the meaning of our entire life.”
Canadian Cardinal Michael Czerny:
"This name is a prayer. When we name the movement now,  every time we name it, we're saying a prayer."
​

  • The movement is now called the Laudato Si’ Movement. A change that has the support of Pope Francis.
  • As part of a two-year synodal process, the mission, values, and structures have also been changed and improved.
  • The Laudato Si’ Movement celebrates and embraces all initiatives born from the encyclical and all organizations working for ecological and climate justice.

   Watch the new name announcement video
Picture
Cardinal Czerny in front of Timothy Schmalz’s ​ Angels Unawares 
Some takeaways: Laudato Si’ ultimately is much more than an encyclical; it represents the Franciscan worldview of praise to the Creator in “sublime communion” with all Creation (LS 89). That Franciscan attitude is the climax of what an ecological conversion looks like and serves as the guiding star of all our efforts. [​As OFS Rule 18 puts it: “Moreover they should respect all creatures, animate and inanimate, which bear the imprint of the Most High, and they should strive to move from the temptation of exploiting creation to the Franciscan concept of universal kinship.”]
 
New mission statement: “To inspire and mobilize the Catholic community to care for our common home and achieve climate and ecological justice.” Grounded in our Catholic identity, we are committed to “a new and universal solidarity” (LS 14), cultivating “fraternity and social friendship” with all humanity (FT 2).
 
The movement brings together a wide range of Catholic (1) organizations and (2) grassroots members from around the world. These members walk together in synodality and communion with the universal Church on a journey of ecological conversion. Seeking unity in diversity, organizational and grassroots members come together to pray, collaborate and mobilize in response to the “cry of the earth and the cry of the poor.”
 
Guided by a spirit of subsidiarity, when the time and context are right, they co-create or engage … on a wide range of initiatives to bring Laudato Si’ to life.” [i.e. “animate”]  We are called to be “Contempl-activists”, cultivating a contemplative “ecological spirituality” (LS 216) and engaging in prophetic activism.
 
In faith and confidence, we walk forward in communion with our wider Catholic family, all people of goodwill, and every creature on our planet singing as we go, praising our beloved Creator, so that “our struggles and our concern for this planet never take away the joy of our hope” (LS 244). 

​

PART 2: INDIAN RESIDENTIAL SCHOOLS
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT

(IRSSA, 2005/6)
What price reconciliation?
How to overcome the legacy of grief that comes from injustice?
Warning: Part 2 may cause discomfort even shame!

I consulted many sources. The more I looked into this issue the more complicated and - at times - confusing, it became. Much has been written and some is unclear, incomplete, unbalanced, inaccurate, confusing and misleading. I have tried to be the opposite! Generally two useful sources are Toronto's website  and Calgary’s website.

First: have remains of bodies been found? Let me quote Dr Sarah Beaulieu (anthropologist, University of the Fraser Valley) who did the research in Kamloops, BC. She said: “We can never say definitively that they are human remains until you excavate, which is why we need to pull back a little bit and say that they are probable burials.” She reduced the number from 215 to 200.

This is because the radar only reveals the location and shape of ground disturbance consistent with a child sized grave. I would add, strongly probable given the survivors oral evidence; and there are surely more nearby. To complicate things, in some places e.g Marieval, Sask, non-indigenous adults and children were buried in the same or contiguous cemeteries that have been barely maintained, if at all, and whose wooden crosses have disappeared or surface stone markers overgrown.

Second: the children at these schools mostly died from the same causes as non-Indigenous children at the time though at a much higher rate. Their deaths were not just a Catholic but a national crime and not murder, but rather exacerbated by neglect and the horrific conditions revealed by Dr Bryce.
Picture
Source: Sandra D Moore, Former Chief, Hiawatha First Nation (Ojibway), Ontario
via Marzio Apolloni (with thanks)
I have tried to summarise and simplify but I am neither an expert nor lawyer. Much as I love the goodness and good people of the Catholic Church I am ashamed of some aspects of the Canadian Church’s response to its 2005/6 agreements to compensate survivors of Indian Residential Schools established under the 1876 Indian Act. Separated from their families, sometimes forcefully, students suffered emotional, physical and sexual abuse, malnutrition, and systemic violations of basic human rights and cultural shaming amounting to cultural genocide in residential schools operated by Catholics, and other Christians. Nor did many get a proper education but were used to work on the land or in housekeeping.
 
However, let us remember, as Archbishop Bolen of Regina said: “There are many important questions about who was fundamentally responsible for residential schools and why were they allowed to function for so long. Stories have surfaced about efforts from 100 years ago to name and put a stop to the disastrous consequences of the residential school policy, drawing attention to voices that should have been heeded. In the society at large and in the Church there were voices that said this was wrong, this should stop or at the very least, we should stop being complicit in what is happening here. Those voices haunt us now." [Indeed! That last sentence is an understatement!]

Archbishop Bolen noted: "Chief Cadmus Delorme [a Cree and Saulteaux, currently Chief of the Cowessess First Nation on whose reserve the Marieval Indian Residential School operated from 1898 to 1997 in the Qu'Appelle Valley, Saskatchewan] has commented how Indigenous and Church people of today have inherited the present situation. I quote, 'Nobody today created residential schools. Nobody today created the Indian Act. Nobody today created the ’60's scoop. We all inherited this.' It’s helpful for us to hear that. But it is for us to rise to the occasion to be instruments of healing and reconciliation." 

Archbishop Bolen added: "It doesn’t help when either the Church or the government deflects their proper responsibilities. With this in mind, we are working earnestly to support healing and reconciliation through this province-wide appeal." The appeal to which he referred is mentioned below.
 
In a tweet of 16 June, Bishop Scott McCaig, CC, Ordinary of the Canadian Armed Forces, succinctly summed up exactly where the Church went wrong, very wrong: “The Church should not have participated in government policy of residential schools. It contradicted our teaching on inculturation and supporting what is good, true and beautiful in a culture. It opposed subsidiarity and centrality of family. May we never sacrifice Gospel principles again.”
How much did Canadian Catholic parishioners who were asked to raise $25 M actually care about reconciliation and right relations with
First Nations, Inuit and Métis?
If money talks then sadly not much. But this is now changing.
[And the same can be said of the Government of Canada].

​The bottom line for the Canadian Catholic Church: it must to do the right thing and pay the full amounts promised to residential school survivors in 2005 as part of a settlement. At one time, the Catholic Church was the only church refusing to pay its 30 per cent share of survivors' claims. It finally agreed but insisted on including an escape clause for the final $25M. The Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement (IRSSA, 2005) was long and complex, so two words inserted into a Catholic side deal got little attention back in 2006. But those two words - "best efforts" - are at the heart of what amounts to a multimillion-dollar renege or betrayal. The IRSSA stated that the Catholic groups that ran the residential schools − the "Catholic entities" − were required to pay a total of $79 million for abuses suffered by survivors.
Picture
​Renowned Canadian sculptor Timothy Schmalz’s newest creation is called Residential School and crafts a classroom with a lone Indigenous girl sitting at one of 14 desks — representing Canada, each province and territory — resting her head with a feather in her hand.
​
​

Photo: Timothy Schmalz (Schmalz builds as others tear down, Quinton Amundson, Catholic Register, 15 July 2021)
With the bishops and many dioceses insisting on the independence of each diocese and order, 16 dioceses and 32 orders were left to fulfill three legal requirements of the 2006 settlement: (1) $29 million in cash payments primarily owed to the Aboriginal Healing Foundation; (2) $25 million in in-kind services over 10 years the Catholic groups would deliver themselves to Indigenous communities; and (3) $25 million to be raised in a major, national fundraising campaign.
 
Have these commitments been met?
In 2015, the Catholic Entities and the federal government disagreed on whether the first commitment of $29 million had been met. Arbitration in a Saskatchewan court ruled that final payment of $1.2 million was owed, so the Catholic Entities paid that money and the judge ruled that all their financial obligations had been met. N.B.: it was the Government of Canada, not the First Nations, Inuit or Métis which released the Catholic Church! Now that is colonialism! It was legal but was it just?
 
The second commitment required the Catholic Entities to provide $25 million of in-kind health, well-being and community services between 2007 and 2017. By 2014, the Catholic Entities had delivered nearly $30 million to community-based projects. Those services continued after 2014, even though the legal commitment had already been met. But as of 26 July 2021, a Church documentation claiming this is sitting inside a Regina courthouse, but officials are refusing to release it.
 
Mayo Moran, a former dean at the University of Toronto's law faculty, who served as independent compensation committee chair for the landmark Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement of 2005, says all parties involved in the 2005 residential school settlement, including the courts, should do everything possible to be open and accountable to survivors. "We need to do everything possible to give survivors the information they deserve.... Do it. Do it quickly. Don't make it more painful for individuals that have already suffered so much."
 
            It is the third legal requirement that was not met, falling $21M short.
 
With a board of Church and Indigenous leaders including Mary Simon, the recently appointed Governor General, and former Assembly of First Nations Chief Phil Fontaine, the “best efforts” campaign was launched into the teeth of the 2008 stock market crash and the Great Recession.                                                                                                                            
While KCI [the corporation hired to fundraise] tried to sign on corporate Canada and large donors, most Canadians, including Catholics, did not know the campaign was going on and at that time were unaware of the history of the schools. When the campaign, in desperation, turned to a pew collection in 2013, only 14 dioceses (out of over 70) participated.

After seven years, and having spent $2 million (which would be standard if the campaign had indeed raised $25 million) with little to show in return, Moving Forward dismissed KCI and decided to hold a special national collection across the country. It was taken up in parishes on 8 Dec 2013, including in dioceses which never operated residential schools.
 
Again the timing was unfortunate: the envelopes hit the pews just a week after Typhoon Haiyan swept through the Philippines. The Canadian Catholic Organization for Development and Peace raised over $13 million for rebuilding projects in the Philippines. This was before the Truth and Reconciliation Commission Report was published online 24 Sept 2015.
 
Let me cite an example of fundraising and ask if it shows a lack of awareness, indifference or imbalance amounting to (forgive my bluntness) an appalling selfishness? While the Roman Catholic Diocese of Saskatoon (which itself never operated an Indian Residential School but signed on voluntarily) and its 80,000 members spent $28.5 million on a new second cathedral (they already had one), they raised just $34,650 for Indian Residential School survivors. The story was similar in other cities. Canada's 12 million Catholics donated less than $4 million of the promised $25 million — roughly 30 cents per person. 
                                                                                                                           
After several years, the Government of Canada told the Catholic Church to pay up. Instead, church officials hired one of Canada's top lawyers, Gordon J. Kuski, QC who charged his normal rates, and in a private court hearing, successfully argued that the country's Catholic churches had tried their best and had no more to give and instead offered $1.2M to settle. On 16 July 2015, after a secret hearing the previous month, Justice Neil Gabrielson sided with the Catholic Church, saying the federal lawyer wasn't clear enough in his opposition to the Church’s proposal and a "reasonable person" would conclude a deal had been struck.
 
Retired Saskatoon Catholic priest and Member of the Order of Canada, André Poilièvre, 85, spoke out against the church to the CBC, saying he's ashamed it used a legal "loophole" to escape its $25-million promise to residential school survivors. "We were complicit with the government in the design, the implementation and the management of these schools … As a Catholic church, we were responsible. We need a collective, corporate response. …It's scandalous, really shameful. It was a loophole. It might be legal, but it's not ethical."
                                                                                                                                             
Mary Ellen Turpel-Lafond is a member of the Muskeg Lake Cree Nation north of Saskatoon, a former Saskatchewan provincial court judge and current Director of the University of British Columbia's Indian Residential School History and Dialogue Centre. She studied the case closely once the results were made public. She said the church betrayed survivors by using high-priced lawyers. She said: "They manipulated the legal system to their advantage. They found a legal back door. I know how that works out when it comes to issues for Indigenous people in Saskatchewan, and in Canada. …They [the church] should go back. They should raise the money, and then some. There is a spiritual and moral deficit here."
                                                                                      
University of Calgary law professor Kathleen Mahoney, who helped craft the IRSSA while working for the Assembly of First Nations, also said she was disgusted. "They relied on these highly technical arguments. It may have worked, but it's not very honourable. It's not moral. It's not ethical," Mahoney said. She also said it's ludicrous for the Catholic churches to claim they couldn't find the money.
 

                That is why I say shame on the Church.
​                         But there is hope...


That is why I say shame on the Church. But there is hope: clerical, religious and lay awareness has grown due to the rediscovery and publicity over the unmarked gravesites and change is coming.
 
St Francis of Assisi eventually realised that the command “Go rebuild my house” did not refer to physical buildings but the spiritual building of the people of God. So what? Surely so that they would act justly and keep promises and not renege.
 
This is a story about the failure of Catholics and their leaders to respond to their role in the federal government’s scheme to erase Indigenous culture and assimilate Indigenous children into white society, said Grouard-McLennan Archbishop Gerard Pettipas. “This was not seen as an issue that was felt equally among the bishops,” he said. “There were those of us who were signatories to IRSSA and those who were not.”   
 
Archbishop Pettipas wants to look ahead now that Catholics are fully aware of what was learned from the hearings and 2015 report by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. “Over the last month, I would say there has been a much stronger engagement, even of faithful Catholics, faithful Catholics who are upset, very upset. … They expect us to do more.” Pettipas believes a more national and unified Catholic response is now necessary. “The reality is that we are independent corporations. That’s true,” he said. “Does that mean that it’s impossible for us to work together as a bishops’ conference?”  
 
“Love thy neighbour” is a key Christian ethic. However, in view of the failure to pay what was originally promised by our senior Canadian Catholic officials, because of the “best efforts” escape clause many grassroots laity are saying we, i.e. dioceses and parishes supported by laity that had no part in operation of the schools, must step up and pay what the Catholic entities originally promised. Some said individuals could divert parish donations in all or in part to organisations that help indigenous people (or to the renewed diocesan appeals). I support that and am going to do just that.
 
A national lay effort to raise funds and awareness for reconciliation is rising up out of the grassroots of the Catholic Church in Canada. Catholics for Truth and Reconciliation is a group that began as a Facebook discussion forum following the recent publicity of unmarked graves, and quickly grew to over 2,000 subscribers. It launched an appeal to all Canadians to raise funds and embrace the Calls the Action set out in the 2015 Truth and Reconciliation Commission report. “It’s very important to do this now,” Jody Garneau , one of the group’s founders, told The Catholic Register. “There’s an immediacy.”
 
As to the Government of Canada, Tasha Kheiriddin in the National Post, 7 July 2021, wrote: “Federal Government spent nearly $100 million over the last three years fighting indigenous communities in court - more than Stephen Harper’s Conservative government over the same time span – despite the promise to reject this “adversarial and “profoundly damaging” approach.” On the other hand, in January 2020 the federal government announced $200 million in funding for “Legacy Projects” related to residential schools, and in June 2021 announced $50 million to fund the new Day Scholar Revitalization Society. As of December 31, 2020, more than $1.82 billion of targeted funds has been allocated to support 694 water and wastewater projects in 581 First Nations communities of which 393 are complete. In December 2020, the Government of Canada announced an additional $1.5 billion to help accelerate the work being done to end all long-term drinking water advisories.                         
                                                                                                                                          
The Catholic groundswell got the bishops’ attention. The Saskatchewan and British Columbia Bishops and Archdiocese of Toronto have announced that they will renew fundraising. These renewed efforts to do the right thing give me hope. Here are four with links to online donation info: Saskatchewan dscf.ca/catholic-trc-healing-response. Vancouver will hold an Archdiocesan-wide Second Collection on the weekend of September 11/12. Donations can be made online here: https://support.rcav.org/archdiocese/archbishops-priorities/donate-to-bc-bishops- a
ppeal/.    
Toronto online through community.archtoronto.org, by phoning 416-934-3411, or through any church in the archdiocese. Surely more dioceses will participate e.g. Calgary. You can check your own diocesan website as more come on board.​
Laudato si, mi signore!
Peace & joy, Andrew Conradi, ofs
Picture
5 Comments
Joseph Glaab OFM
8/11/2021 03:37:30 pm

Thank you Andrew! May we continue on the path of truth and reconciliation.

Reply
George Guimond link
8/15/2021 10:39:12 pm

Posted for Andrew Conradi and copied to Joe:
"Don, thank you for raising an important question. Truth & Reconciliation is about way, way more than money. Money is only part of it; possibly the easiest part. "The Canadian Catholic Church" made a promise in an agreement then failed to deliver and tried to wiggle out of it. A grassroots movement of laity, clerics and religious who see ourselves as part of "The Canadian Catholic Church" have pushed to honour the promise. It is as simple as that.
Awareness and accompaniment are more important in the long run. My parish (OLOR, Victoria together with the Bishop) is meeting with Indigenous people this coming Sunday afternoon & evening to listen and engage to find a way forward. It will not be quick or easy but we must try. Peace & joy, Andrew, ofs"

He adds this link: https://www.catholicregister.org/item/33384-reconciliation-goes-beyond-money?mc_cid=24c77dee38&mc_eid=b664ffdb59

Reply
Don MacAlister
8/12/2021 12:34:33 pm

Why does Reconciliation always seem to be about Money ?. One group demanding a cash payment from the other offending group to make up for someone's bad behavior from many years ago. Throwing money at problems even though our government seems to do that continuously is not really an answer as the act of doing that can cause great harm as well.

Reply
George Guimond link
8/15/2021 10:37:40 pm

Posted for Andrew Conradi:
"Don, thank you for raising an important question. Truth & Reconciliation is about way, way more than money. Money is only part of it; possibly the easiest part. "The Canadian Catholic Church" made a promise in an agreement then failed to deliver and tried to wiggle out of it. A grassroots movement of laity, clerics and religious who see ourselves as part of "The Canadian Catholic Church" have pushed to honour the promise. It is as simple as that.
Awareness and accompaniment are more important in the long run. My parish (OLOR, Victoria together with the Bishop) is meeting with Indigenous people this coming Sunday afternoon & evening to listen and engage to find a way forward. It will not be quick or easy but we must try. Peace & joy, Andrew, ofs"

He adds this link: https://www.catholicregister.org/item/33384-reconciliation-goes-beyond-money?mc_cid=24c77dee38&mc_eid=b664ffdb59

Reply
Paul Michael Leo Vanderham
8/15/2021 05:34:12 pm

Thanks, Andrew, for shedding light on the funds still left owing after the Church's "best efforts" to raise $25 million by way of compensation for its contribution to harms caused by the residential schools. Like you, my wife Mary Anne and I will be diverting funds from our local parish in favour fundraising efforts focused exclusively on restitution/reconciliation. We would like to maintain the diversion until the $21 million left owing has been paid, but we're wondering how we'll know when the time has come. Non of the bishop-led initiatives you mention seem to be referencing the $21 million left owing. Any suggestions?

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Homeless Jesus - Jesuits.ca

    Andrew Conradi, ofs

    ​What makes me tick is Catholic Social Teaching, now encapsulated in Laudato Si’ and Fratelli Tutti. My view is that while the OFS Rule & Constitutions call us to courageous action in JPIC it seems to me our infrastructure, while saying the right things, is not always acting with the required urgency and forcefulness. It seems at times to be more self-sustaining and self-perpetuating and about the status quo. This risks being seen as irrelevant in the eyes of some, especially youth.

    Picture
    ​In encouraging us to be aware and act with urgency and forcefulness I can be seen to be a bit of a joyful nuisance. Forgive me for not apologising. “Jesus himself warns us that the path he proposes goes against the flow, even making us challenge society by the way we live and, as a result, becoming a nuisance.”
    (Pope Francis, 2018, Gaudete et exultate – Rejoice & be glad, n 90)
    After all, Our Seraphic Father Francis was a rebel (check out the 2018 book Francesco il ribelle by Enzo Fortunato, OFM Conv)
    Picture
    ​(Poster from Canadian Jesuits)
    BTW I am a Brit immigrant, ex Canadian high school geography and history teacher and Cold War armoured reconnaissance soldier. Other accomplishments include OFM JPIC Animators course 2014, Pontifical University Antonianum, Rome; JPIC Animator; Provocateur (Challenger); Enfant Terrible and sometimes definitely a deliberate NUISANCE! I am open to correction, chastisement, and/or teaching by email!
     apconradi@telus.net

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

SPEAKING UP FOR THE VOICELESS IN OUR WORLD
© Franciscan Voice Canada
All rights reserved 2020
Action 
Blog
Newsletters
News
​Resources
Links
Contact Us